Auction Market Theory provides a logical framework for understanding how markets discover value. This knowledge is fundamental for interpreting any price chart.
Theory Fundamentals
Auction Market Theory as we know it was born primarily from the studies of J.P. Steidlmayer on Market Profile. Subsequently, along with other authors like James Dalton and Donald L. Jones, they defined a series of concepts that constitute this theory.
Fundamental Principle
The theory is based on the fact that the market, with the priority objective of facilitating negotiation between its participants and under the principles of supply and demand, will always move in search of efficiency, also known as equilibrium or fair value.
Efficiency vs Inefficiency
Market Efficiency (Equilibrium)
Efficiency indicates that buyers and sellers are comfortable trading and neither has clear control. That comfort comes because, based on current market conditions, the valuations of both are very similar.
The way this equilibrium is visually observed on a price chart is through continuous rotation (trading ranges). These price consolidations represent said equilibrium. It is the evidence of trade facilitation and is the state where the market always seeks to be.
Market Inefficiency (Imbalance)
On the other hand, we have moments of inefficiency or imbalance, and these are represented in trending movements. When new information reaches the market, it can cause the value perceived by both buyers and sellers about said asset to change, generating a disagreement between them.
One of the two sides will take control and move the price away from the previous equilibrium zone, offering us an exploitable trading opportunity. What is evident in this context is that the market is not facilitating negotiation and therefore it is considered an inefficient condition.
The Continuous Market Cycle
The market will constantly move in search and confirmation of value; in situations where buyers and sellers are in a position to exchange stock. This cycle will repeat over and over without interruption.
The general idea is that the market will move from one equilibrium zone to another through trending movements, and these will begin when the market sentiment of both buyers and sellers about current value differs, causing the imbalance. The market will now begin searching for the next area that generates consensus among the majority of participants about value.
Connection with Wyckoff Methodology
It should be noted that the market spends most of its time during equilibrium periods, which is logical given the nature of the market based on favoring negotiation between its participants. This is where those accumulation and distribution processes take place, which as we all know is where the Wyckoff methodology focuses.
The Three Price Variables
The auction process in financial markets has value as its fundamental basis. To try to decipher where such value is located, three additional elements need to be evaluated:
Price + Time + Volume = Value
- Auction Market Theory
1. Price as a Discovery Tool
In the auction mechanism, price is used as a discovery tool. Trade facilitation is carried out through price movement, which fluctuates up and down exploring different levels with the objective of seeing how participants react to said exploration.
These price movements announce opportunities. If participants respond to that exploration by perceiving the price as fair, it will trigger negotiation between them. Conversely, if those discoveries of new price levels are not perceived as attractive to both participants, it will cause rejection.
2. Time as an Opportunity Regulator
When the market promotes an opportunity (reaches an attractive level), it will use time to regulate how long that opportunity will be available.
The Time Rule
Price will spend very little time in those zones that are advantageous for one of the two sides (buyers or sellers). An efficiency or equilibrium zone will be characterized by greater time consumption; while an inefficiency or imbalance zone will be represented by brief time consumption.
3. Volume as an Interest Indicator
Volume represents activity, the quantity of an asset that has been exchanged. This quantity suggests interest or disinterest at certain levels.
Based on volume, some zones are more valuable than others. The basic rule is that the greater the activity seen in a given area, the greater the value that market participants assign to it.
Logical Perspective
These three elements are responsible for offering us a logical perspective about where, based on current conditions, market participants consider the value of a particular asset to be located.
Through price, the market discovers new levels; time consumption suggests that there is some acceptance in that new area; and finally, volume generation confirms that participants have created a new value zone where they trade comfortably.
As we know, conditions are changing and therefore continuous reevaluation of these elements is needed. Knowing where value is located is key since it defines the market condition, and based on this, we can propose different trading ideas.
Value Perception
The market is constantly rotating between two phases: horizontal development (equilibrium) or vertical development (imbalance). Horizontal development suggests agreement between participants while vertical development is a market searching for value, searching for participants to trade with.
Horizontal Development (Equilibrium)
The fact that price is moving comfortably within a trading range (horizontal development) represents acceptance in that zone; it is a context where price and value coincide according to participants.
Fair Value and Range Extremes
In an equilibrium area, the fairest price will be located in the middle part, and the extremes both above and below will represent unfair or unaccepted levels by participants:
- Range highs: Perceived as expensive by buyers / cheap by sellers
- Range lows: Perceived as cheap by buyers / expensive by sellers
Price naturally reverts toward the center where equilibrium is.
Vertical Development (Imbalance)
When the market is in a trending state (vertical development), price and value do not coincide; in this context, price will move ahead and value will follow it or not (as a sign of acceptance and rejection).
The trader's task is to evaluate now whether those new price quotation levels are accepted or rejected. Price goes ahead of the other two variables when determining potential value areas, but it is time first and volume last that will confirm whether that new area is accepted or rejected.
Range Trading
Based on the fact that the fairest value is found in the center of the range, a movement to the upper extreme will be seen by buyers as an expensive price and at the same time sellers will consider it cheap, so their actions will lead to sending price back to the fairest zone.
Similarly, a visit to the lower extreme of the range will be seen as cheap by buyers and expensive by sellers, which will cause a new rally.
Classic Range Strategy
This is nothing more or less than the typical range trading that everyone knows, where the goal is to buy at lows and sell at highs, expecting price to continue rejecting those extremes. And normally the market will continue like this until its condition changes.
Acceptance vs Rejection
The interesting part comes when an imbalance occurs and price leaves the value zone. What will happen then? When price leaves a trading zone, a change in value perception can occur.
Two Possible Outcomes
- Acceptance: price manages to stay (consumes time) and contracts begin to be exchanged between buyers and sellers (volume), represented as a certain price consolidation
- Rejection: price quickly reverses back to its old value zone denoting lack of interest, evidenced by a sharp reversal
Confirmation Needed
A vertical movement by itself does not guarantee that new value has been found. It needs confirmation from time (price remains in the zone) and volume (there is real interest in trading there).
The Market Cycle
Horizontal development ends
When there is no longer agreement between participants about value. New information or context change generates disagreement.
Vertical development begins
Price searches for new zones where consensus can emerge. One side (buyers or sellers) has control.
Vertical development ends
When price reaches a zone where there is agreement between participants again. Participants accept the new valuation.
New horizontal development
New equilibrium is established. The cycle restarts awaiting the next change in perception.
"All horizontal developments end when there is no longer agreement between participants about value; while all vertical developments end when price reaches a zone where there is agreement between them again. This is the continuous market cycle."
- Auction Market Theory
This idea in itself is very powerful and with proper planning, trading strategies could be built around it.
Universality: It is important to note that auction theory is universal and therefore serves us to evaluate any type of financial market regardless of the timeframe used.
Practical Application
As with one of the universal principles of technical analysis (price discounts everything), we do not need to evaluate what really produces that change in value perception by participants.
We know that based on current conditions, based on the information available at that precise moment, all participants give a valuation to the asset's price. Subsequently, something fundamental may happen that changes that perception, but the beauty of this approach is that it removes the need to know and interpret what has happened for participants' perception to have changed.
Auction Market Theory provides logical perspectives on:
- Where market participants consider an asset's value to be located
- Whether the market is in equilibrium (range) or searching for value (trend)
- When a price zone is accepted vs rejected
- Eliminates the need to interpret underlying fundamental catalysts
Analytical Advantage
You don't need to know why participants change their perception of value. You only need to identify when and where that change is occurring through the analysis of price, time and volume.
Wyckoff 2.0
This article is an excerpt from the book. If you want to master Auction Market Theory along with Volume Profile and Order Flow, the book provides all the knowledge needed for advanced trading.
View book
